Below is an example of documentation and reflection completed by Gev. Kimmel, Clyde and Adon Kaufman. As you read through their process, please think about the following questions:
- What did they do well?
- What could they work on?
- How can this example help you in future challenges? EXTRA CREDIT- How can this help you in other classes? Projects? Etc.?
- What is one thing you can choose to work on after seeing this example?
Please respond to these four questions in the comments section of this post.Â
Challenge Create an animal out of a bag of legos
Chat Captain: Adon Kaufman
Materials manager/Recorder: Gev. Kimmel
Timekeeper/facilitator: Gev. Clyde
Planning/Brainstorming 12/3/17
Kaufman asked us each to share our favorite animal. Penguin, Elephant and Dog were shared. Elephant may be hard to do because of trunk.
We decided to sort our pieces by color to see if that would help us think more clearly. We had a lot of red, could we make a cardinal?
We decided with three people it would be hard to all be using the legos at once. We would set a 2 minute timer. Each person would get two minutes to touch and manipulate the legos and then we would switch. Between each turn we would take 30 seconds to provide feedback and think about how to move forward. We all agreed not to get upset if someone changed something we made.
Our inspirationÂ
First Attempt 12/5/17
Gev. Kimmel started and used 5 red legos and one black lego. (forgot to take picture)
We all agreed that it was a good start. Our suggestion to Adon Kaufman was to try to add wings to make it look more bird like.
Kaufman added two more red pieces to add wings and a feather on top of the head. We all agreed that the wings worked by feather seemed confusing because it wasn’t centered.
Gev. Clyde removed the top feather and spent some time really studying our inspiration. We pushed her to get working but she said she saw the benefit in studying the actual cardinal. She added feet but still could not figure out how to add a feather to the top of the head.
Feedback
We shared our cardinal with Gev. Jirovetz. She loved our initial design. She had a few suggestions…
- It was hard to tell that the black on the head was a beak because it didn’t stick out like a beak would.
- She looked at our inspiration and suggested finding a way to but a point on the top of the head of the bird.
- She liked the wings and feet but thought maybe the wings could spread out longer to distinguish them from the body.
Reflection
- We used our time really well by allowing each member to manipulate the materials for two minutes at a time.
- Planning was really helpful and gave us a clear vision.
- We definitely need to re-look at our pieces and see if we can figure out a way to spread the wings longer and make a more distinguished feather and beak.
- We were not very patient with Gev. Clyde while she was building. Kaufman, as chat captain, had to remind us not to yell at her but we still did. How can we avoid this in the future?
Planning
Maybe we can use some of the longer flatter pieces to spread out the wings and make the beak stick out.
We will continue rotating who touches the legos but give only one minute each so that we each get to touch them more than once.
Second Attempt
Gev. Kimmel took apart the original design and spread the wings out further.
Kaufman then tried to figure out how to make the beak. He took it apart several times, got frustrated and asked to rotate early.
Gev. Clyde put the black piece so that it stuck out from the front. We all agreed that it helped and that Gev. Kimmel should focus on the feather on top.
Gev. Kimmel referred back to the inspirational picture and realized that the beak was supposed to be red, not black. That the beak pokes out of black feathers. She switched the red and black but everyone agreed it looked better how they had it. They compared now to the picture above and then time was up.
Kaufman took what they had and quickly changed it back and added the feather on top.
Feedback
Leah R. guessed a cardinal because of colors, wings and the mouth and feet. She thought it was clearly a cardinal!
Eva A. suggested moving the feet outward because bird feet don’t point stick out to the side.
Final Reflection
- We worked really well as a team. We were respectful of each other today by not criticizing each other and keeping our focus on building a cardinal.
- Feedback was really helpful and we were thankful for it, especially the specific feedback.
- Even though it was hard to get critical feedback, we needed it to move forward.
- It was helpful that we were all OK with taking it apart and rebuilding– we knew that it was OK to fail and start over.
- We were so glad we had our chat captain to keep us focused. There were a few minutes when we got off task and he reminded us to keep an eye on the timer.